Criminalizing Poverty | Bangalore , India by Ayush Ranka
7:27 am in Community, Photojournale Publishing by John
http://www.photojournale.com/categories.php?cat_id=188
In August of 2010, Bangalore witnessed the tragic death of over 40 inmates at the “Beggar’s Home” on Magadi Road. The home was overcrowded with an estimated 2500 inmates squeezed into infrastructure that was meant to accommodate about 500 people. Reports indicate that contaminated food served (ironically) on Independence Day, triggered the incident. Five months later and the Beggar’s Home has been sanitised. The number of inmates is somewhere in the vicinity of 300. The walls are freshly painted, the floors look clean but there still remains a vacant stare in the eyes of the inmates.
The incident in August turned the spotlight onto the issue of how the state is criminalising poverty. The Karnataka Prohibition Of Beggary Act, 1975[1] makes begging a crime. What’s written between the lines of the act is that poverty is a crime, particularly if you are in state of absolute poverty. The sentence for the crime of poverty is custodialisation (read as jail sentence). There is a process laid out in the law to make the arrest and pass sentence. In actual practice the process is followed superficially. Most inmates can’t defend themselves either because they can’t speak the language or do not understand what is happening to them. For example, there are innumerable cases of people having been picked for “looking poor”.
Inmates that the journalist met and spoke to come not only from parts of rural Karnataka but also from areas such as Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odissa, Bihar, Rajasthan, West Bengal, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka. There is a common thread of destitution and poverty in their journey lines. It’s not laziness that they are being punished for, it’s their poverty. Many of these inmates are mentally challenged and are being pushed over the brink by the process of custodialisation and being jailed like a criminal. What they need is a facilitative health care program and not a jail sentence.
There is an urgent need to stop incarcerating people only because they are poor and in a state of destitution. Proscriptive Laws that criminalise poverty need to be replaced by voluntary and rehabilitative policies that empower people out of poverty. We need to look deeper at complex root causes such as inequitable economic models and historical oppression through the caste system.
If we breed poverty, we have to deal with – not hide it in a jail cell. The aesthetic sensibilities of “shining India” can not come at the cost of somebody else’s right to freedom and dignity.
This photo essay is shot on the streets of Bangalore and during two visits to the Beggar’s Home in Decemeber 2010 and January 2011.
Please note: There are no portraits in this essay. The reasoning is that since these people are already being traumatized by society and have no particular identity, wrongly giving them an identity would harm their dignity and go against the principles of the project at this point in time.
[1]The Karnataka Prohibition Of Beggary Act, 1975
Biography
Ayush’s influence in photography took birth at a very young age. He grew up feeding his eyes on images from magazines like the National Geographic, Reader’s Digest, Time, Life and others, in which every picture was a story in itself. Not knowing the full impact that the pictures would have, was a boon in itself. It saved him from going through the intricacies of the “opinion” of judging one against the other. Everything was up for grabs.
On a holiday with his family in 1993, shooting on film on a Kodak K10, he took pictures of two things, among many, monkeys along Pushkar lake and the Humayun’s Tomb in Delhi. But it was not the pictures themselves that made the impact on him. It was the sheer thrill of the lingering excitement of seeing the final result on print and the feeling of reliving that moment in his mind and heart. The light, sounds, scents of something that’s history, and a very personal one. To him, photography is something that is private. His individuality is derived from it and his photographs in turn are consequential of this. He believes that any form of art has a very important role to play in fostering a sense of understanding between people in a very direct and unadulterated manner. And photography to him, is the most immediate.
- Freelancing since 2002
- August 2007 to June 2009 – Lecturer in Photography and Digital Imaging at National Institute of Creative Communication (NICC), Bangalore.
Key Projects and Assignments
- Coverage of the Tsunami in coastal Tamil Nadu [2004]
- “Pictures that speak” for the Dalit Foundation. Created a photo-library on Dalit movements, occupations and customs. [2005]
- “Born with Cerebral Palsy” – A project on the lives of children affected by cerebral palsy. [2008]
- ‘Bangalore Bar Culture’ – A small photographic narrative on Bangalore’s age old under belly, the local bars. [2009]
- “Namma Metro” A photo essay on the impact of the Metro Rail construction project in Bangalore (unpublished). [2010]
- Compiling a photo essay for PUCL, (People’s Union of Civil Liberties), about Bangalore ‘Beggar’s Home’ to raise awareness on the need to decriminalize poverty. [Phase I completed in 2010]
- Multiple editorial assignments for Femina magazine. [2002 – 2010]
Exhibitions
- “Unforgettable – The First Pictures” was held in 2003 in Bangalore.
- A participant in a group exhibition sponsored by Bangalore Rotary Club in 2004
Recognition
2007 ‘Honorable Mention’ at the first ever PX3 Prix De La Photographie competition, Paris, for the series on the Tsunami disaster of Dec 2004.
2008 ‘Honorable Mention’ at the PX3 Prix De La Photographie competition, Paris, for the series on the Pushkar Fair, Rajasthan.
2009 Was one of the top ten short-listed photographers of the Redux Scholarship for the Foundry Photojournalism Workshop, Manali, India.










